It's all about the Resume Author: TriSecDate:08/02/2008 12:59:34
Good Morning.
By now, you've probably seen Senator McCain's latest TV Ad. But if you haven't I'm sorry you won't get this 1:14 of your life back.
This ad actually struck me as generally favorable towards Obama...but then there's Moses. (Hey, I thought Barack was Muslim, but I digress). Others have called the ad offensive and stupid.
But does it ask a legitimate question? "Is he ready to lead?"
Much has been made this election cycle about Senator Obama's "inexperience". Yet, in our presidential history, so very few men have had any *real* experience at being president and have gone on to do great things. Conversely, those with mountains of experience that should have made them great presidents have ended in disaster and disgrace.
What makes anyone ready to be president? There's no training program, no college course, no apprenticeship for the job. Every single president we've had walked into the office not knowing what was going to happen on January 21, and learned and adapted on the fly.
So...let's do a little experiment today. I've gone back through history and put together a brief resume for 7 likely candidates for the office. Please read them carefully and decide who you might vote for based on their experience. I'll post a poll; please pick before you go in the blog. The candidate's names will be posted inside.
Candidate A: Attended Yale, member of "Skull and Bones" Was a county assistant prosecutor and tax collector Appointed Solicitor General of the United States for one term Member of US Sixth Circuit court of Appeals Apointed Secretary of Defense for one term
Candidate B: Completely home schooled, no formal education Lost first campaign for State Legislature Eventually was elected, served four terms in the State Legislature Elected to US House of Representatives; served one term Retired from politics; worked as a defense attorney for several years Ran for US Senate and lost
Candidate C: Was an economics and sociology major Served in the US Army Elected president of his professional union Served two terms as a state governor Ran for president and lost the first time Was out of public office for four years
Candidate D: Graduated last in his class Served in the US Navy Spent 6 years in prison Elected to US house of representatives; served two terms Elected to US Senate; served 4 terms Was involved in a campaign finance scandal; cleared by his Senate colleagues Member of Senate Armed Service committee Chairman of the Senate Commerce Committee
Candidate E: Attended private schools; graduated from Harvard Served in the US Navy Won his first campaign for US House of Representatives; served 3 terms Wrote a book; won Pulitzer Prize Won his first campaign for US Senate; did not complete term before running for President
Candidate F: Was Rhodes Scholar; Graduated from Yale Law School Worked on one presidential campaign as a low-level staffer Ran for the US House of Representatives and lost Was elected state Attorney General in an unopposed election Ran for governor and won; served two terms
Candidate G: Spent much of his youth overseas Attended Columbia and Harvard Law Taught Constitutional Law for 12 years Ran for state senate and won; served 3 terms Lost first campaign for US senate; became chairman of state Health and Human Services committee while out of office Ran for senate again and won, member of Foreign Relations, Environment and Public works, and Veteran's affairs committees. Chairman of European affairs subcommittee
Candidate H: Worked for US Geological Survey Spent much time overseas, overseeing many US mining concerns Was caught in a war while overseas; wife worked in local hospitals while he helped defend the city and rescue trapped children Invented process to recover zinc lost in mine tailings Was strong advocate for immigration, said 'immigrants work 20% harder than anyone else Helped rescue over 100,000 Americans trapped overseas by a major war Was head of war relief effort; spent two years organizing delivery of food and supplies to 9 million war refugees Was appointed Secretary of Commerce Directed local relief efforts after catastrophic flood in US; his organization prevented widespread disease and helped local population quickly recover after flood subsided.
Again I ask, who has the experience to be president? I daresay no one. What's important is more abstract...does the candidate have the intelligence and temperment? Does he show more than a passing awareness with the issues that really matter to Americans? Is he ready to step onto the global stage and work with other world leaders as partners? Does he talk to you, or talk down to you?
These are the things that matter. Who are you going to vote for?
[on edit: I seem to be having a problem creating a poll this morning; it didn't save properly, and now I can't see it. Nevertheless, please pick a candidate before proceeding into the blog. - TriSec]